Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite wrote a very thought-provoking article on the recent murder of George Tiller, an abortion provider in Kansas. You can read the article and dozens of comments at http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/panelists/susan_brooks_thistlethwaite/2009/05/the_killing_of_george_tiller_a_pro-life_murder.html.
I would like to comment on her attribution of violence to the pro-life movement:
“‘Pro-life’ as the self-description of the anti-abortion movement has a fundamental flaw at its heart. The moral absolute of “life” is not applied consistently, in my view, by the majority of those in this movement. Many in the “pro-life” anti-abortion movement seem to me to only be pro-life in the case of abortion — unlike those who hold an ethic of life across a range of moral issues, not only abortion but also war and the death penalty, This makes “pro-life” in regard to abortion not only an inconsistent ethic, but an unstable one.
“Nothing exposes this fundamental inconsistency and instability in the ethic of life as a description of the anti-abortion movement more than “pro-life” murder.
“Violence has been a part of the anti-abortion movement from the beginning, from the overt violence of the murder of other abortion providers to the covert violence of harassing women trying to get to clinics for reproductive services.”
Her general statements about the violence of the pro-life movement are reflected in a sweeping generalization made by the National Abortion Federation: “Since the 1973 Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision that made abortion legal, there has been an organized campaign by anti-abortion extremists which has resulted in escalating levels of violence against women’s health care providers.”
The irony is not lost on anyone: pro-life murderers. But is it true? Here are the results of statistics compiled in the US from 1965-2008 and reported by Human Life International:
Individual murders, manslaughters, and infanticides committed by pro-abortionists (not counting women killed by “safe and legal” abortion procedures – 941.
Women killed by “safe and legal” abortion procedures – 365
Total number of people killed by pro-abortionists – 1,306
Number of people killed by pro-lifers – 7
I am pro-life, and while I recognize the nuances between killing and murder as reflected in the Christian tradition (thus I am “pro-life” when it comes to the innocent, but “pro-judgment” when it comes to the guilty), I believe that it is wrong for an individual to take the law into his or her own hands and murder a fellow human being, as the murderer of George Tiller did. The above numbers, however, strengthen the case that the vast majority of those who call themselves pro-life do indeed value all lives.
The Christians I know believe the same things. In fact, many of my Christian friends are so strongly pro-life that they give freely of their means to support a ministry that provides free pregnancy screenings and promotes alternatives to abortion. A number of Christian friends have adopted children as an alternative to abortion. (They also minister to those in prison and to their families who are dealing with the incarceration of a loved one.) Lest one think I live in a Christian vacuum, the small number of murders by pro-life people over 33 years leads me to believe that the pro-life movement is strongly oriented to the sacredness of all life, even those with whom they disagree.
Cardinal Justin Rigali of Philadelphia issued this statement in response to Tiller’s murder: “Our bishops’ conference and all its members have repeatedly and publicly denounced all forms of violence in our society, including abortion as well as the misguided resort to violence by anyone opposed to abortion. Such killing is the opposite of everything we stand for, and everything we want our culture to stand for: respect for the life of each and every human being from its beginning to its natural end. We pray for Dr. Tiller and his family.”
Ms. Thistlethwaite has stained the pro-life movement with too broad a brush. George Tiller’s murderer is not in the mainstream of pro-life people. The statistics bear out that the vast majority of pro-life people are, as Cardinal Rigali states, respectful of all human life.
Recent Comments